(no subject)

[leia131]

I'm posting like a madwoman, I know, you don't need to tell me. But I just have to put this out there. DO NOT CLICK THIS LINK IF YOU HAVE NOT FINISHED HBP!!! Well. I am sort of "borrowing" the basic idea for this, but go with me. If R.A.B. is in fact Regulus Black, and if he did in fact steal the real locket Horcrux, then this is a much more interesting phrase then it used to be: "also a heavy locket that none of them could open" OotP, Pg.116, when they are cleaning out the Black family's cabinets. Then again, sometimes a locket is just a locket. And R.A.B. may not be Regulus. And even if it is, he may have succeeded in destroying the Horcrux. Who knows? But I found it an interetsing conspiracy theory, and who doesn't love a good Harry Potter conspiracy theory? Just the ranting of a posting madwoman. Pay it no mind if you don't want to.

Comments

[zartlila.livejournal.com]

If indeed that was the locket, I think it is likely Mundungus sold it when he sold some of the other things from the Blacks' house.

[leia131.livejournal.com]

Mmm but I believe they threw the locket away.

However, the Mundungus stealing things theory has been raised as well.

[zartlila.livejournal.com]

was it possibly one of the things Kreacher saved?

[leia131.livejournal.com]

Oh that's possible as well. In fact, the possibilites that phrase raises are now almost endless.

Cool huh?

[btwnluvnhate.livejournal.com]

okay i am somewhat convinced its regulus just from a few theories i read.

1) there has to be some reason jk mentioned a random locket in OotP. Same thing goes for Regulus

also Kreacher could have played a role in getting the locket, remenber how the boat could not hold 2 wizards, kreacher wouldn't count.
and i think regulus is mentioned one or two times in HBP in regard to the slug club. something about being an excellent potions students
yeah i am really not this smart i just read muggglenet editorials
but yeah i am half-way convinced that r.a.b is regulus but the only draw back is that it all seems to easy to point to regulus

[leia131.livejournal.com]

All excellent points. I agree.

And I know Regulus seems obvious, but there have been many things in the HP universe that I thought were too obvious to be true, and then they turend out to be fact. So that doesn't sway me.